Find out why Advanced Powder Dynamics is your next liquid to powder solutions partner.

Scale-Up and Toll Spray Drying: Preserving R&D Optionality

TL;DR

Transitioning a formulation from small-scale lab R&D to full commercial production presents significant technical and financial risks. When working with toll spray drying and contract powder processing, technical teams often rush parameters—such as inlet/outlet temperatures or atomization energy—before fully understanding their impact on yield and particle morphology. By taking a multidimensional approach, R&D teams can run small-scale batch trials with various formulations side-by-side. Utilizing dynamic atomization technology allows for precise control over droplet formation, enabling target particle size distribution and targeted morphology early in development. This technical control, paired with real-time financial and operational modeling, gives project leaders, supply chain directors, and executive leadership the data required to evaluate cost curves, ingredient consumption, and yields across scale. Ultimately, maintaining optionality late into the commercialization pipeline prevents premature processing decisions and ensures predictable, high-volume production runs.

Preserving Formulation Optionality in R&D Lab Trials

Ulli: Alright. I’m Uli Vendauer. I’m the chief marketing officer at Tesseract Life Sciences. This is an interesting podcast today for me because it is going to be quite technical, but it is also going to be very critical for planning everything in terms of production, product performance in the marketplace, product performance for the consumer, which is usually the perspective from which I operate, which is all customer and consumer oriented. This will be very interesting. Let’s dive into the first question, which is when a company has a new powder formulation that works in the lab, what does the path look like to get it into commercial production? And what are the stages specifically?

Hendrik: Yeah. Let me start with that. Once we have developed or confirmed a formulation with a customer, and we develop many different, formats for formulations. It could be single ingredient formulations, multi ingredient formulations, it could be emulsions, it could be inclusions, micro encapsulation requirements. All of these different formulations require very specific processes in the development steps that we are going to follow. Advanced Powder Dynamics has built in house process development steps during the last, I would say, ten years that focuses specifically on customer requirements. After we have confirmed the formulation or formulations with the customer and we have their approval, the next step would be the first step in drying the product for the customer. We have three focus areas. The first one is, the liquid handling or the liquid preparation of the feed product.

Hendrik: The second step would be, the drying process itself, round settings and the round conditions. And then the third phase of this first step is the product evaluation itself. On the liquid preparation and liquid handling side, we focus on, and again, depending on the type of formulation, how do we prepare the formulation, what mixing is required, temperatures, viscosity, and feed solace concentration. These aspects are critical when you have to determine powder properties and powder characteristic requirements. You also have to ensure that you have a scalable process on the liquid handling side and liquid preparation side as you go through the development process up to the full commercial scale. The second part of that is the settings and the run conditions. And typically, would look at inlet temperatures, outlet temperatures, atomization energy, the kinetic energy that we put into the dryer itself to disperse the product, to atomize the product, and to derive the product.

Hendrik: We also look at how the product conveys through the system and how it behaves in different phases of the system. That is the drying chamber, the cyclone finds it, passes the cyclone to the bag house, and we look at, initial product yields so that we can prepare for the next level of the process. The third focus area is power properties and characteristics based on the customer expectations. And these expectations are based on, the delivery system that the customer has, is that is there solubility requirements, is there particle size requirements, density and so forth. We have an in process lab where we can evaluate the powder that we produce in real time and make specific adjustments, know, based on the lab results. I have to say that this first step in the drying process is our pilot scale dryer.

Hendrik: It’s a five pound per hour evap dryer, so it represents 1% of our full scale commercialization dryers. What’s important is that it uses our unique dynamic atomization technology. Everything that we achieve on the first level, this pilot scale dryer trials, we know that we can scale this up to the next level. And depending on the objectives of the customer, the campaign level objectives, whether it’s mid sized dryer campaigns or full scale dryer campaigns, we know that we can scale this up and achieve the specific objectives for the customer, which includes the liquid preparation, the drying itself of the product to achieve that powder and powder properties that the customer require. The second step in our in our process would then be after we achieved, the initial expectations of the customer.

Hendrik: And let me add, we always invite customers to attend these first level trials so that they can observe, the process, they can learn our technology, and they get to meet the team. It’s important for us that while we are doing these initial trials, we build confidence with the customer, and they understand the technology. They understand the process that we are going to take them through full. To full commercialization. The next step then, after we achieve the initial results, is we scale up to our mid sized dryer, which is a 50 pound per hour dryer. It’s also one of the dryers that we use for medium volumes productions. It’s it’s critical that once we achieve something on the pilot scale dryer, we have to confirm that we can achieve this on a higher level and on longer run times.

Hendrik: We will extend the run time and run for at least six to eight hours on the dryer to see if the liquid behaves the same during the six hours or eight hours. There’s no changes in viscosity, in salt concentration. We look at temperature influence on the liquid side. And then we look at the dryer process itself and we ensure that, during this extended run times, we achieve the same yields or the expected yields. We look at conveyance through the system to ensure that there’s no bull up., it’s it’s always easy to run a product for two or three hours and everything goes well. But after the dryer stabilized and the skin temperature of the dryer is stable, you may start experiencing buildup, or you have excessive fines that bypass the cyclin to the bagasse.

Hendrik: All of these aspects are critical to observe and to determine and to make sure that you achieve the expectations from a yield perspective, from a power of property perspective, before you scale up to full production.

The third step is scale up demonstrations. And again, depending on the volume requirements of the customer, we can we can do this on the mid sized dryer, or we can do it on our full scale production dryer. And this is where we we move from the development process to the optimization and the final scale of demonstration process to ensure that when we do a full scale production and we run 10 shifts or 20 shifts, that we can achieve the objectives of the customer. We look at batch size optimisation, we look at optimisation of yields, we look at packaging materials and how we’re going to package and how much volume we’ll put into every package or packaging option, and we finalize the powder property specifications with the customer. And that is when. At that stage where we can start planning for full commercial campaigns and talk to the customer about pricing, optimize volumes, and scheduling requirements.

Will: , the interesting thing about this, Steven, is that, there’s there’s a whole lot that Hindrick related, and it’s largely very technical Yeah. In many of these aspects. A lot of equipment, a lot of process, a lot of engineering behind both. But one of the things that at least our customers love about us, our factory, our process, our team, the way we go about these things is that we bring the entire team. Know, Uli and I are both, coming from a business school background and more of a management background that looks at commercialization from a financial strategic market perspective. And one of the things that we were always taught is that the heart of strategy is preserving optionality. And so there are two things about how we approach our customer relationships and our partnerships that are very important here.

Will: And it starts with the preface to your question, which was about a formulation coming out of the lab. What we do at the lab level is we try to give customers as many potential formulations as possible and carry those potential formulations into the r and d and the drying process on our small scale dryer so that they can test those formulations against one another and preserve those options on the equipment until they see how they perform. Because we’re. What we’re able to tell them on the benchtop in the lab is hopefully that multiple formulations are viable. But you don’t know until those formulations hit the equipment how things are gonna perform on the machinery. Because at benchtop, it’s about viability. It’s not really about precise performance. It’s not until we get them on the machinery that we can start to engineer the particle and see how those particle flow through the equipment.

Will: And what we will often, very often, do for them, usually with the customer standing right there next to us seeing it in real time, is do batch after batch with different formulations in each batch so they can test them against each other one after another along with real time projections of what that performance is gonna be that they can put into their business plan with curves of what the ingredient buying is gonna be at scale, curves showing what that yield is gonna look like for each one of them all the way through commercialization at very high volume on our largest production dryers so that they can produce a business plan for each one of them within a couple hours of bringing things into the factory even at the r and d scale. And, I love my team because we bring all of the functions so that our clients can unify their management team around what they’re seeing.

Will: The project leaders, their CFO, their COO, their supply chain, the CEO, herself, himself, can all see what they need in the output from our factory because we take a multidimensional approach, and we help them sort through things. It may sound technical, but embedded in everything they get from us, test the optionality of all of these different potential formulations and outputs against one another so they can they can really see everything they need to see from all the different lenses and the intersection points to determine what may be best for their business.

Ulli: Yeah. No. I love that. That’s that. That’s why I’ve said this before, but, there. There’s a certain aspect of the way that you guys go through this manufacturing and development process that I think is so unique, not even just to your industry, just unique in that not many companies, I think, take the same level of care to not only the technical side, but being able to give better data to make better decisions with.

Will: Yeah. And I think. I don’t know. We have a slide that Uli likes to use if, if we pass that to you and can show it or not. But one of the values of what we do is preserving that optionality deep into the process of commercialization so partners have the ability to go up into scale and make that decision at the right time in the process of scaling rather than make it prematurely before they have the information they need and therefore Mhmm. Not being forced to sacrifice margin or sacrifice capabilities in the product or select the wrong supplier or make a decision that unfortunately limits them and then realize in hindsight that they could have made a better decision.

Ulli: That brings us to our next question, which is what are the most common things that break when you try and scale up the spray drying process from a small r and d batch to a full production run? I know we touched on this in the last, answer. Even just a brief touch on this though, I think is a good question still.

Hendrik: , Steven, if you asked me this question ten years ago, I would have, it would have been an easy answer.

It’s if you work with equipment, mechanical maintenance is, and equipment maintenance is always an issue. It used to be an issue. But, if you have a well established, preventative maintenance program, you have the latest technology and the latest tech. The equipment, such as what APD have, then those things are not a concern if you have that maintenance. Preventative maintenance plan, in place, and you ensure that you have proper process design before you scale. And that is why it’s a common mistake that, customers make to think that the r and d process is just a step, to get to commercialization and we need to get this as soon as possible.

Hendrik: But there are many focus areas and most people would say, listen, we’ve sprayed rised this before or we tried this before and we know the inlet temperatures, we know the outlet temperatures, which is common comparisons between our technology and conventional spray drying, and we know what the atomization energy is. You should be good. You can do this. And again, we go back and we have to explain to customers every step of the process is critically important to determine what your success for the next phase. Again, you have to look at the liquid handling and the liquid preparation. You have to look at how are you going to design the process itself to achieve the product and the product quality that you that you that you expect at the end of the run.

Hendrik: And that includes particle size, and particle size includes particle engineering, it includes configuration design and different nozzle applications and nozzle configurations. And all of these things are critical so when you go through the process to eventually get to commercialization is to ensure that you design the equipment, process, and the drying ground settings and conditions so that you can have a successful campaign. And then we’ll just touch this briefly. One thing that can break in that is customer trust and customer confidence. And that is that is critically important for us to ensure that the customer is aware and is updated during this process from the very first step during the lab evaluation to the first step of the pilot scale trial trials, to optimization trials, through scale of demonstration, to commercialization, that they understand every step of the process that we designed for them and every aspect that we achieve with regards to their expectations so that they know when they invest in a full production run, we are going to achieve what they expect us to achieve.

Will: Yeah. I would say that a lot of times, the things that break are invisible, and the client won’t even notice that something has broken until months later. And we had an example recently with a client whose chain of custody broke on their materials before they were delivered to us for processing. And we realized it, and so we dealt with the issue. And we had an issue recently where customers’ pain of custody was broken on materials that they were sending to us. And in this case, the materials were supposed to be stored, refrigerated, and it’s not clear how long these materials were or not as they were passed between logistics carriers. And in that situation, you’ll have materials, you’ll have a finished product that’s not gonna have the stability of the shelf life that it should have had.

Will: And when they’re going bad, on the shelf after processing in the customer’s hands out in the market, then the client will certainly notice it. But they’ll notice it and not understand what’s happening. And if we hadn’t picked up on it before they were processed, it, would have been a real problem for them in the market. And so we were able to correct it. But in this case, it. It’s not a manufacturing issue. It was a quality and handling issue in the supply chain. But as I said, it was virtually invisible. And so I think the message is that clients have to pay attention to everything that’s going on in the manufacturing process, whether it’s on the manufacturing floor, it’s on the machinery, or it’s a process that leads into that actual manufacturing.

Ulli: I honestly. I love the way that both those two perspectives balance out with each other because two of the biggest takeaways that I got from them, obviously, there are the technical aspects. But even just the care to detail. The care for detail rather from both of you in regards to Hendrik even listing out sometimes the things that break are client trust if you don’t have that attention to detail. And then the other things being the very non obvious, the chain of custody, things that are invisible. It’s just, I think that’s why these perspectives are so useful, why these talks are so useful because you guys bring such a such a layer of experience and caring about the details that it makes a really, really helpful answer to these questions, think.

Will: It’s a little bit like cooking. Right?, even if you don’t like to cook, most of us like to eat. And as the saying goes, if you wanna have quality food, you have to have quality ingredients. And so everyone should make sure that they know what’s going into their products and take care of them.

Ulli: Yeah. That’s a that’s a great analogy. Moving on to the next question here. How does particle behavior change at different production scales and how do you account for that when you’re engineering a powder?

Precision Particle Engineering via Dynamic Atomization

Hendrik: Yeah. I. Again, there is there’s two focus areas here. The first one is the technology that is applied. And advanced aerodynamic have a unique technology that we have discussed during previous interviews and that is dynamic atomization technology, which gives us the ability to have very specific control over droplet forming and thus particle size engineering and particle size, particle morphology and particle size distribution. Those things are critical and our technology gives us the ability to once we achieve this particle size distribution or this particle properties, we know that we can scale it up to any next level in our production lines. Second to that is what else influences particle morphology, particle size and how do you control that? And again, it is when you design a process, it includes a liquid handling side.

Hendrik: If you have different viscosities, you have different temperatures than the liquid feed and you have different salt concentrations, that is going to influence what you get out at the end of the run.

Those things would directly influence the particle size, the particle size distribution and morphology of the particle. Well again, he addressed this very well now. What you put in is what you’re going to get out. As long as you have the same liquid feed every single time regardless of the scale that you use, And you have the same run settings and the run conditions. And you have developed the the the best dryer configuration, including the nozzle configuration and the atomization energy that you put into atomizing the product, you will achieve the same product at the end of the run.

Bridging the Gap Between Small-Scale Trials and Commercial Scale-Up

Ulli: Do you guys have anything to add to that?

Multi-Lens Modeling for Procurement and Executive Decision-Making

Will: It’s it’s hard to follow Hendrik who’s such an expert on these things, but it’s Yeah., it’s it’s really about repeatability and breaking things down to the lowest common denominator Mhmm. And building repeatability around those things. We try to be very precise. And that’s not to say that, we don’t have challenges with some things., it’s it’s hard to be exact every single time over and over for every campaign, but we understand what the tolerances are. We work with those tolerances, and we try to make everything repeatable each time and monitor very closely in real time, and that seems to work.


Frequently Asked Questions

How does toll spray drying help mitigate technical risks during commercial scale-up?

Toll spray drying allows processing teams to test multiple formulation variations on small-scale equipment before committing to capital-intensive commercial production runs. By analyzing real-time performance, particle morphology, and yield data at the pilot level, engineers can optimize process parameters without interrupting existing operations. This flexible approach preserves formulation optionality deep into development, ensuring scalable parameters are established before high-volume manufacturing.

What is dynamic atomization and how does it affect particle size distribution?

Dynamic atomization technology provides precise control over energy transfer during droplet formation within the drying chamber. Unlike conventional atomization methods, it allows engineers to tightly control droplet size, particle morphology, and overall particle size distribution. This fine-tuned control is critical when optimizing powder for specific bulk density, flowability, or encapsulation requirements in contract powder processing.

Why is preserving formulation optionality important in contract spray drying?

Preserving optionality prevents engineering and procurement teams from prematurely locking in process conditions before complete scale-up data is available. Testing various formulations side-by-side during initial lab evaluations provides clear visibility into ingredient consumption, operational yields, and cost projections. This data-driven strategy ensures that the selected parameter set yields consistent quality and performance at high volumes.

What parameters are evaluated during pilot-scale contract powder processing?

During pilot trials, technical teams evaluate inlet and outlet temperatures, feed viscosity, dynamic atomization energy, drying kinetics, and particle size reduction services data. Additionally, non-thermal performance variables and mass balances are measured to generate accurate yield and throughput curves. These metrics allow supply chain and operations teams to project exact manufacturing costs and ingredient buying needs for commercialization.

How do lab-scale spray drying projections translate to full-scale manufacturing performance?

Lab-scale projections translate directly to commercial performance by utilizing scalable thermodynamic and aerodynamic models tailored to specific equipment configurations. By collecting precise data from R&D batch runs, technical teams create multi-dimensional output curves that forecast operational costs, material yields, and throughput at scale. This step-by-step validation ensures full-scale production runs match original trial expectations.

Advanced Powder Dynamics is the premier choice in high-value, non-commodity spray drying contract manufacturing and powder product innovation. Let us be your next liquid-to-powder solutions partner.